TCF review of the Mighty 3, a kid-friendly, screen-free music player

Stepping up the ladder of technology

Generally, I think my children knowing my very clear views on technology is a good thing.

I believe using tech wisely and well is important¹ — that it’s a key to a flourishing life! — and just as I hope they come to agree with other values I hold dear, I hope they see the wisdom in this one, too. So John and I engage them openly and frequently about the pluses and perils of technology, what it does to our brains, the importance of choosing how we use our time, and the special joy of real-world experiences. We encourage them to grow in empowerment and self-advocacy. And we model, imperfectly, how to live a happily low-screen life.

The danger, as I see it: one day, knowing how strongly I feel about technology, they will feel their only way to access a device or app or experience is to go behind my back and do it in secret. They’ll mistake my strong feelings for unfeeling rigidity, and they’ll give in to the temptation of the forbidden fruit.

This narrative — that kids held back behind their peers from something desirable, whether technology, alcohol, or freedom of movement, will eventually rebel and overindulge — is often given by parents as the reason for handing over devices earlier than they’d planned. Though it sounds realistic and somewhat virtuous, I don’t buy it — but I do acknowledge it.

And so, in our conversations about technology, I try to really listen to my kids’ desires and concerns. If they say they want a “phone,” what is it that they really want? Connection? To fit in? Autonomy? Or something more mundane, like the ability to count their steps, read an ebook, or listen to a podcast?

Once we get specific, it becomes so much easier to find a solution together — and in doing so, to remind them that I’m on their side, not their enemy, when it comes to technology.

The key to doing this in a way that works for both of us is the ladder of technology. It has one rule: always choose the simplest option that still allows you to do what you want to do. To use a popular example around here, you might hand your child a Yoto player instead of a phone when they want to listen to an audiobook.

The most recent small problem we set out to solve in our family? June wanted to listen to music in her room.

June is ten, finishing up fourth grade. She’s a delightful kid, responsible, and, in general, happily on board with our family’s low-screen vibes. So when she expressed the desire, over many months, to be able to listen to the music of her choice in her room, I wanted to make this happen for her.

I considered the options:

Should we go with the boombox of yore? Collecting CDs felt tedious, though, and she wouldn’t be able to listen to our family’s curated playlists.

Should we go with an Echo Dot? Having a smart device in a kid’s bedroom felt like a big leap; I needed to do more research to feel comfortable.

Should we expand our collection of Yoto music cards? Yoto has been adding music cards at a great clip. They have over 300 available now, including many June would love — Wicked, Sing, The Sound of Music, Rend Collective — but building up our library would quickly get expensive.

In the midst of deliberating, another option fell into our lap: the team at Mighty graciously sent us a Mighty 3 to try out and review. We’ve had it for a few weeks now, and I’d love to tell you about it and share our thoughts!

What is the Mighty 3?

The Mighty music player is a tiny, screen-free, easy-to-use device that allows kids (or grown-ups!) to listen to the music of their choice without screens or distractions. It holds 1000+ downloaded songs and has an 8+ hour battery life, allowing kids to listen to music on the go without an internet connection or outlet.

Through the parent app, you (or your child) can choose the playlists or albums to load onto the Mighty. The child can take it from there, toggling between songs and playlists to their heart’s content.

The Mighty does not have a built-in speaker and is meant to be used with Bluetooth or wired headphones.

You can learn more here!

What we love about the Mighty3:

• It is tiny, cute, and easy to use. Though the package comes with minimal instructions (a la Apple), we pretty quickly figured out how to load playlists and start listening. The small size is appealing to June — she likes that she can clip it onto her clothes and move about the house, reading and listening. The color options are also really fun and playful! They have a robust Support Center if ever needed.

• The music is curated. The Mighty offers maximum parental peace of mind: based on what’s been loaded via the parent app, you can know exactly what your child is listening to, with no content surprises. June loved getting to choose which playlists to load and even creating her own Spotify playlist. (We named it the Mighty Mix!)

• It is screen-free and offline. No distracting notifications, no ads, no voice control or AI programming. Again, max parental peace of mind, very similar to the Yoto.

• It allows June to listen to the music of her choice! A successful step up the ladder of technology that makes us both happy.

What doesn’t work as well for us:

• Spotify will no longer be supported starting April 21, 2027, due to changes to Spotify’s platform. This is very recent news (it happened between my communication with Mighty and writing this newsletter) and it is a bummer for our family. We pay for Spotify Premium and have built our musical ecosystem, including dozens of playlists, there. Next year, the Mighty will connect exclusively with Amazon Music.

• It is tiny. The Mighty 3 is just 1.5 inches square, which makes it delightfully portable — but for young kids still learning responsibility with their belongings, I worry that it could easily be misplaced. June and I talked about this, and she decided to leave it in her bedside table drawer when she’s not using it.

• It can be tedious to sync playlists. Important to note: Mighty highly recommends only syncing one playlist at a time, which we did. Still, most playlists took 7 or 8 syncs to fully download, which can make the initial set-up slow.

• It is not built for listening with friends. It turns out that when June imagined listening to music in her room, she was picturing a communal experience — being able to have music on in the background when she had a friend over or was playing with siblings. Though the Mighty can connect to a Bluetooth speaker or a speaker with an aux input, it’s not really built for either — it’s meant to be a personal listening device. I will also add that, as a parent always eager for insight into what my kids are into, I’d love to be able to hear what she’s pushing play on. Since she’s wearing headphones, her listening habits are more opaque.

Safety precautions to consider:

Overall, the Mighty 3 feels super safe — which makes me so grateful! However, there are a few things to consider whenever your kids start interacting with Spotify more independently. I recommend making these three moves now:

1. Turn off explicit content. Go to Settings —> Content and Display —> toggle off Allow explicit content. We already had this set up because our kids request songs through our downstairs Echo.

2. Turn off messages. Go to Settings —> Privacy and Social —> toggle off Messages. Whyyyyyyy is this even a thing.

3. Turn off Canvas and video. Go to Settings —> Content and Display —> toggle off Music videos, Canvas, and Other videos.

---

Overall, the Mighty 3 is a fantastic, easy-to-use personal music player that might be just the right step up the ladder of technology for your child. Thank you again to the Mighty team for sending it our way — we will continue to use and love it!

And in the meantime, I think I will continue my research on Echo Dots, with an eye toward potentially gifting one to June for Christmas later this year. Chris McKenna’s guide, as always, will be my first stop, but I’d love to hear from you all in the comments: Are your kids able to listen to music independently/in their rooms? Have you tried out an Echo with your kids? Any recent steps up the ladder of technology you’d like to share? Let’s hear it!

---

Will you consider hearting this email? ❤️

Clicking the little heart icon at the bottom or leaving a comment helps these posts to reach more people (and also makes my day!). If you liked what you read, would you consider clicking the heart or leaving a comment? Thank you so much in advance!

1. Understatement